Blue Jays fall to Royals in series opener as late rally comes up short
The Toronto Blue Jays lost the first game of their series against the Kansas City Royals, falling to 64-69. Despite a strong performance from rookie Brett Bateman and Max Scherzer limiting runs, the Blue Jays were unable to capitalize on opportunities, ultimately losing 5-3. They seek to rebound in the upcoming games.
Photo: Sean Pollock
The Toronto Blue Jays could not turn a late offensive push into another comeback, dropping the opener of their three-game series against the Kansas City Royals at Rogers Centre.
Toronto fell to 64-69 on the season and 33-34 at home, while Kansas City extended its winning streak to a season-high nine games. For the Blue Jays, the loss also continued their struggles at the beginning of series, where they are now 20-24 this year.
Max Scherzer kept Toronto within striking distance through five innings despite battling command issues, while Brett Bateman continued the impressive start to his major-league career with three hits. The Blue Jays eventually mounted a push in the ninth behind Nathan Lukes, but could not complete the comeback.
Scherzer battles through five innings
Scherzer’s night required him to work around traffic almost immediately. Carter Jensen opened the game by driving a 107.4 mph four-seam fastball for a single and eventually came around to score, giving Kansas City an early advantage.
Even without his sharpest command, Scherzer prevented the game from getting away from Toronto. He completed five innings, allowing two runs on four hits while striking out four. His five walks were a season high.
The 42-year-old generated nine whiffs, including three on just five swings against his curveball. His recent work at Rogers Centre has also remained strong, with a 2.25 ERA across 16 innings over his last three home starts.
Scherzer’s four strikeouts brought his career total to 3,525, leaving him nine away from tying Hall of Famer Gaylord Perry for ninth on MLB’s all-time list.
Kansas City added to its advantage in the fifth when Salvador Perez delivered an RBI single. The veteran extended his hitting streak to six games and continued a productive career against Toronto, against whom he owns 14 home runs and 39 RBI in 70 appearances.
Blue Jays unable to capitalize against Seth Lugo
Toronto put runners aboard against Royals starter Seth Lugo, but struggled to translate those opportunities into enough runs.
Lugo scattered six hits and allowed only one run over five innings, striking out five and walking one. He generated a season-high 12 whiffs, including five with his curveball.
It continued an impressive career trend against Toronto. Lugo has now faced the Blue Jays eight times, including four starts, and owns a 4-1 record with a 2.40 ERA over 30 innings.
One of Toronto’s most consistent threats came from Bateman at the top of the lineup.
The rookie singled in the first, fifth and ninth innings to finish 3-for-5 with two runs scored. It was already his second three-hit performance in only 15 major-league games.
Bateman has recorded at least one hit in 11 of those games and is batting .328 through his first 64 at-bats. Among Blue Jays hitters with at least 70 plate appearances through their first 15 career games, only Bo Bichette’s .394 average in 2019 was higher.
His production has been particularly notable since moving into the leadoff role. Across 10 games batting first, Bateman is hitting .372 with an .833 OPS.
Toronto makes one final push in the ninth
Andrés Giménez also provided consistent traffic on the bases, reaching three times. The infielder doubled to centre in the second inning for his 20th two-base hit of the season, added a single in the fourth and was hit by a pitch in the seventh. Giménez finished 2-for-3 and has now reached 20 doubles in four different major-league seasons.
Toronto still entered the ninth needing a comeback, and Bateman provided the spark with his third hit of the game.
Lukes then brought home two runs with a single as the Blue Jays attempted to turn the final inning into something more. He finished 2-for-4 with a walk and two RBI, recording his 22nd multi-hit performance of the season.
Late situations have been one of Lukes’ strengths throughout the year. From the seventh inning onward, he is hitting .317 with 15 RBI and an .832 OPS. This time, however, the rally stopped before Toronto could erase the deficit.
Blue Jays searching for response at Rogers Centre
The defeat leaves Toronto five games below .500 with the calendar moving toward September and little margin remaining in the final weeks of the regular season.
There were individual positives in the opener, from Bateman’s continued emergence to Scherzer limiting the damage on a difficult night and the offence showing life in the ninth.
They were not enough to produce the result Toronto needed.
With two games remaining against Kansas City, the Blue Jays will now look to respond at Rogers Centre and prevent the Royals’ nine-game winning streak from turning into a series victory in Toronto.